Twelve at work; three waiting their turn
Mark’s working palette is organised around twelve colours, with Azo Yellow, Pyrrol Red and Phthalo Blue Turquoise available as three optional extras. Lemon Yellow now occupies the top-left well; Azo has moved to the auxiliary set. The photograph is the reference for the current arrangement.
The direction is a Daniel Smith palette, replacing paints as they run out. This guide concentrates on the colour choices and their positions. A familiar box is more useful than an urgent shopping list. The twelve are available to choose from; one or two may be all a study needs.
Read the box in the same direction as the photograph
The layout is part of the method. From left to right the columns are yellow, red, blue and green. From top to bottom the rows are Modern Accent, Traditional Colour, then Classic / Base / Body. Keep those positions when making a chart: turning the bottom row into the top row changes the map your hand is learning.
Read across to try a complete row. Read down to choose between three ways of doing a colour’s job. Then cross the rows: a yellow from one, a red from another, whichever blue fits the subject, and a green that earns its place. The box is organised; the painting is allowed to wander.
Four columns. Three rows. Smaller palettes within.
Same orientation as the photograph: yellow, red, blue, green from left to right. Modern at the top, traditional in the middle, classic / body at the bottom.
Modern Accent
- Lemon Yellow
- Quinacridone RosePV19
- Phthalo Blue · Green ShadePB15:3
- Rich Green GoldPY129
Traditional Colour
- Isoindoline YellowPY139
- Pyrrol ScarletPR255
- French UltramarinePB29
- Phthalo Green · Blue ShadePG7
Classic / Base / Body
- Raw Sienna LightPY42
- Permanent BrownPBr25
- Indanthrone BluePB60
- Perylene GreenPBk31
Outside these twelve wells: Azo Yellow, Pyrrol Red and Phthalo Blue Turquoise. Pick a limited set from the twelve, or use an auxiliary for a particular job.

The rows describe a way of thinking
At the top, Modern Accent runs Lemon Yellow, Quinacridone Rose, Phthalo Blue Green Shade and Rich Green Gold. In the middle, Traditional Colour runs Isoindoline Yellow, Pyrrol Scarlet, French Ultramarine and Phthalo Green Blue Shade (PG7). At the bottom, Classic / Base / Body runs Raw Sienna Light, Permanent Brown, Indanthrone Blue and Perylene Green.
The row names describe working roles, not a chronology of pigment invention or a shared paint property. The bottom row offers structure and restrained colour; the middle row gives a traditional working choice; the top row supplies a different, brighter direction. Test each as a small palette before deciding what it does for your subject.
Why three blues and three greenward colours?
The blues are not three versions of the same decision. Indanthrone offers a deep blue starting point; French Ultramarine brings a granulating option; Phthalo Blue Green Shade provides an intense mixing blue. Daniel Smith’s current chart lists all three as transparent, but their other characteristics differ. Test them at similar lightness as well as straight from a strong puddle.
The green column is deliberate: Rich Green Gold at the top, Phthalo Green Blue Shade in the middle and Perylene Green at the bottom. They offer yellow-green, a strong cooler mixing green and a deep green-black direction. Rich Green Gold has a yellow pigment code, PY129, but belongs in this column for the job it does. Daniel Smith’s name for the PG7 colour is Phthalo Green (Blue Shade).
One colour is already a palette
Indanthrone Blue is Mark’s one-colour starting point. It can carry a whole study through changes in dilution, connected values and edges: leave the paper for the lightest light, use a pale blue for the broad middle, and reserve the stronger mixture for a few deep notes. The subject does not need twelve pigments to become legible.
Try a Liverpool street or a simple jug in three values using PB60 alone. Ask whether the big shapes still read when the colour choices are removed. If they do, you have a painting structure. If they do not, a new yellow will be a very cheerful distraction.
The two middle wells in the bottom row
Permanent Brown PBr25 and Indanthrone Blue PB60 sit beside one another in the centre of the classic row. This is Mark’s body pair: the route to his base-tone neutral grey. It is a mixture of those two colours, not a separate grey pan and not a demand for equal quantities.
Push the same pair towards brown for a warmer passage, towards blue for a cooler one, and adjust between them for the neutral that suits the picture. Water then changes its strength. Keeping both pigments available through a study gives brick, sky and shadow a shared relationship without making every shape the same grey.
Why this supports the paintings Mark wants to make
Mark’s practice values transparency, gesture, colour interaction and visible decisions. A palette with both restrained structural colours and strong accents offers a useful way to separate a broad connected wash from a small interruption. The useful question is not whether twelve pigments can imitate every object. It is whether they make the relationships the picture needs.
Try building a modest colour world with Raw Sienna Light, Permanent Brown and Indanthrone Blue, then introducing one stronger accent. Or take one colour from each column and make a deliberately limited study. These are exercises drawn from the organisation of the box. They help reveal which colours you reach for repeatedly and which are merely enjoying the ride.
Know the actual paint, not just its code
The colour map uses familiar paint names; put the pigment code from your own tube beside your physical swatches. A name such as Lemon Yellow is not a universal recipe across manufacturers. French Ultramarine and Indanthrone Blue also differ in handling, so compare a pale wash and a strong passage rather than judging only the dark paint in the pan.
For Mark’s transparent passages, the amount of paint matters alongside the product rating. Make pale washes as well as strong swatches. Introduce a powerful phthalo a little at a time and keep a clean mixing area. The pigment can be perfectly useful and still take over the meeting if you give it the whole table.
Lemon in the core; Azo alongside
The swap is now made: Lemon Yellow is in the twelve; Azo Yellow joins Pyrrol Red and Phthalo Blue Turquoise in the auxiliary three. Azo has not been rejected. It is another yellow choice when the subject benefits from it, while the core keeps Lemon, Isoindoline and Raw Sienna Light as its three yellow-column options.
For this arrangement, a cooler lemon makes a useful contrast with the warmer yellow and earth below it. That is a practical reason for the choice, not a claim that lemon is universally better. Paint the same green with Lemon and with Azo, then compare a warm wall mixture. The dry paper will tell you what each choice buys.
A limited palette inside a larger box
Twelve wells are a set of choices, not a twelve-colour minimum. A whole row offers four related starting choices. Taking one colour from each column offers 81 possible four-colour selections from the core: three yellow choices × three red choices × three blues × three greens. That counts selections, not guaranteed successful mixtures. The painting still gets a vote.
The three auxiliary colours widen the choices to fifteen when they help. Choose the small working set before you begin; an extra may replace one choice or add one specific note. A one-colour painting, the two-colour body pair and a four-colour selection are all legitimate uses of the same box. You are finding palettes within it, not trying to empty every well onto the paper.
One view, three small palettes
- Draw the same simple street or still life three times, postcard size. Keep the light and dark shapes consistent. Allow drying time between stages.
- First paint with Indanthrone Blue alone. Use dilution and paper white to make three clear values.
- Paint the second with the two centre wells of the bottom row: Permanent Brown and Indanthrone Blue. Mix a warm, a near-neutral and a cool version; use those relationships through the painting.
- For the third choose one yellow, red, blue and green, writing each row and column position beside its name. Cross the rows if that suits the subject.
- Compare the dry studies. Name what the third and fourth colours added. Only then repeat a small passage with one auxiliary colour and decide whether that extra actually helped.
Make this a study of your own subject. These are our practice prompts, not a claim to reproduce an artist’s exact method.
Take a practice sheet →Keep looking
- Mark C Grant: studio and paintings
- DANIEL SMITH Watercolor Pigment Characteristics — official live table
- Daniel Smith: Phthalo Green (Blue Shade), PG7
Sources support the factual context; looking notes and exercises are Watercolourist editorial interpretation.
